For anyone considering selling property in New York State or New York City, the term “transfer tax” might evoke a mix of confusion, concern, and a desire for clarity. Transfer taxes, levied at the seller at the time of property sale, add another layer of expense atop an already high cost of entry into real estate. This blog post aims to demystify these taxes, critique their impact, compare them with other U.S. jurisdictions, and provide insights on managing or reducing their financial impact when buying a home.

Transfer Tax in New York: An Overview

New York’s real estate transactions are subject to multiple transfer taxes:

• New York State Transfer Tax: 
  • 0.4% for properties sold under $3 million.
  • 0.65% for properties sold at $3 million and above.
• New York City Transfer Tax (RPTT – Real Property Transfer Tax):
  • 1.0% for properties sold under $500,000.
  • 1.425% for properties sold at $500,000 or more.

In addition, homebuyers typically pay mortgage recording taxes (if financed) and mansion taxes which are cumulative, meaning they stack on top of each other, significantly increasing the total cost of property transfer that can exceed 8%! 

Detailed Tax Tiers

New York State Transfer Tax:

New York City Transfer Tax:

Critique of Transfer Taxes

• Economic Impact: High transfer taxes can deter property transactions, affecting market liquidity. Buyers might find alternatives in less taxed areas, potentially impacting NY’s real estate market.
• Cumulative Effect: When combined with the Mansion Tax and Mortgage Recording Tax, these taxes can represent a significant portion of the closing costs, sometimes reaching or exceeding the down payment for buyers.
• Disproportionate Impact: While aimed at generating revenue from high-value transactions, the static nature of tax thresholds means even moderately priced properties can incur these taxes, affecting middle-income buyers more than intended.
• Market Distortion: There’s an observed behavior where properties are priced just below tax thresholds to avoid higher rates, leading to market inefficiencies.

Comparison with Other U.S. Cities and States

• California: Cities like San Francisco have transfer taxes that increase with property value, but they lack the additional NYC Mansion Tax or Mortgage Recording Tax.
• Florida: No state transfer tax exists, though counties might impose their own.
• Texas: Does not have a state transfer tax, making it attractive for real estate investments from a tax perspective.
• New Jersey: Has a uniform transfer tax rate, which is lower compared to NYC, with exemptions for certain transactions.

Origins and Evolution

The transfer tax in New York State was established in the early 20th century to fund state operations. Over time:

• 1906: The state of New York introduced the transfer tax, marking the beginning of a structured taxation on real property transactions to fund state operations.
• 1959: NYC introduced its version of the transfer tax, initially at lower rates.
• 1969: The NYC transfer tax was increased from 0.5% to 1% for properties under $500,000 and 1.425% for those above, reflecting the city’s growing need for revenue.
• 2019: New York State adjusted its transfer tax, implementing a higher rate of 0.65% for properties sold for $3 million or more, aiming to capture more revenue from high-end transactions.

Strategies to Mitigate or Avoid Transfer Taxes

• Negotiation: In some cases, especially in new developments or buyer’s markets, developers might absorb part or all transfer taxes to close a sale.
• Co-op vs. Condo: Co-op purchases often avoid the NYC transfer tax since they’re technically not real property but shares in a corporation. However, co-ops might have their “flip taxes.”
• 1031 Exchange: For investment properties, a 1031 exchange can defer capital gains, though it doesn’t avoid transfer taxes directly.
• Seller Concessions: In some transactions, sellers might agree to pay these taxes as part of the negotiation, though this is less common for high-value properties like a $4 million condo.
• Utilizing Tax Abatements: While not directly avoiding the transfer tax, certain properties might qualify for abatements that could offset other costs, making the overall financial impact less severe.

Illustration of Transfer Taxes on a $4 Million NYC Condo

Conclusion

The transfer taxes in New York, while contributing to public finances, pose a significant hurdle for prospective homeowners, especially in the already expensive NYC market. They add layers of complexity to real estate transactions, potentially impacting affordability and market dynamics. For buyers, understanding these taxes, their historical context, and strategies to mitigate their impact is crucial. While some might view these taxes as necessary for urban development, there’s a strong case for reviewing their structure to ensure they do not stifle the very market they depend upon for revenue. This blog aims to equip buyers with the knowledge to navigate this aspect of residential financing, highlighting the need for perhaps a more nuanced approach to property taxation in New York.

Lock It In!, LLC can Mitigate These Costs

What if there were options to mitigate the transfer tax?  Now it can be deferred or reduced by using the proprietary lease-option product offered by Lock It In!, LLC.   Visit LockItInFinance.com or email LockItIn@LockItInFinance to learn how our product lowers the cost of your NY State or NYC home, benefiting both buyers and sellers.  

References:  

https://www.nyc.gov/site/finance/property/property-real-property-transfer-tax-rptt.page#

https://www.tax.ny.gov/bus/transfer/rptidx.htm